Centre-State & Inter-State relations
Key facts
- Part XI covers legislative and administrative relations; Part XII adds fiscal federalism through Articles 268-293.
- Parliament enters State List space through Articles 249, 250, 252 and 253, each with different triggers.
- Article 254 repugnancy applies to Concurrent List conflicts; Presidential assent may protect State law until Parliament overrides.
- Article 263 Inter-State Council is recommendatory; Zonal Councils are statutory under the States Reorganisation Act, 1956.
- Article 279A GST Council has weighted voting; Mohit Minerals, 2022 made its recommendations persuasive for primary legislation.
Key Points at a Glance
- 1
Part XI covers legislative and administrative relations; Part XII adds fiscal federalism through Articles 268-293.
- 2
Parliament enters State List space through Articles 249, 250, 252 and 253, each with different triggers.
- 3
Article 254 repugnancy applies to Concurrent List conflicts; Presidential assent may protect State law until Parliament overrides.
- 4
Article 263 Inter-State Council is recommendatory; Zonal Councils are statutory under the States Reorganisation Act, 1956.
- 5
Article 279A GST Council has weighted voting; Mohit Minerals, 2022 made its recommendations persuasive for primary legislation.
- 6
Article 356 is judicially reviewable after S.R. Bommai, 1994; federalism is part of the basic structure.
- 7
Finance Commission under Article 280 recommends tax devolution and grants; Article 293 controls borrowing by indebted States.
- 8
Article 262 permits special adjudication of inter-state river water disputes and exclusion of ordinary court jurisdiction.
Continue studying
Constitutional frame and exam scope
Centre-State relations are the constitutional arrangements through which the Union and the States share law-making, administration, revenue, security duties and dispute-resolution space.
- Starting point: Article 1 describes India as a Union of States; this matters because States are constitutionally recognised units, not mere administrative departments of the Union.
- Core location: Part XI covers relations between the Union and the States. Articles 245-255 deal mainly with legislative relations; Articles 256-263 deal mainly with administrative coordination, directions and the Inter-State Council.
- Financial layer: Part XII adds Articles 268-293 on distribution of revenues, grants, borrowing and financial procedure; Finance Commission provisions in Articles 280-281 are central to fiscal federalism.
- Subject division: The Seventh Schedule distributes subjects through the Union List, State List and Concurrent List. The Union List has defence, foreign affairs, atomic energy, railways, banking, currency and many national subjects. The State List covers public order, police, public health, agriculture, local government and intra-state trade. The Concurrent List covers criminal law, education, forests, labour welfare, marriage, bankruptcy and several shared fields.
- UPSC focus: Questions rarely ask the slogan of cooperative federalism. They ask whether Parliament can legislate for a State subject during national interest, emergency, state request or treaty implementation; whether State law survives repugnancy; and whether a federal body is constitutional, statutory or executive.
- Conceptual balance: India is federal in distribution of powers but has strong unitary features: single Constitution, single citizenship, integrated judiciary, emergency powers, all-India services and residuary powers with Parliament.
- Practical reading rule: Do not study Centre-State relations as only conflict. The Constitution creates command provisions, consultation forums, fiscal transfers, adjudicatory mechanisms and political negotiation channels together.
- Prelims trap: Inter-State relations are not only river disputes. They include Article 263 coordination, Zonal Councils under the States Reorganisation Act, 1956, inter-state trade freedom under Articles 301-307, and statutory councils for sectoral cooperation.
Open the complete note
This public page shows the first available section. The study pack opens the complete topic with all revision material.
8 more sections in the complete note
Open study packPredictedPredicted Questions
Use these prompts to test answer structure before moving to practice.
1MCQConsider the following statements about Parliament legislating on State List matters: 1. Under Article 249, the resolution is passed by Rajya Sabha. 2. Under Article 252, a law once made by Parliament can be amended by the consenting State legislatures. 3. Article 253 can operate without a national emergency. Which of the statements is/are correct?
Explanation
Statement 1 is correct. Statement 2 is incorrect because amendment or repeal of an Article 252 law is by Parliament, not the State legislatures. Statement 3 is correct; Article 253 implements international obligations.
~50 words · 1 marks
