Skip to main content

Ethics

Quick Revision Table

AI vs. Conscience in Administrative Decision Making

Paper II · Unit 1 Section 11 of 12 0 PYQs 24 min

Public Section Preview

Quick Revision Table

Concept Key Fact RPSC Relevance
AI in administration Pattern recognition, predictive decisions New 2026 topic — high probability
Algorithmic bias AI replicates training data discrimination Welfare exclusion, policing examples
Accountability gap "Problem of many hands" (Floridi) Who is responsible when AI errs?
Black-box problem Unexplainable AI decisions Natural justice, Article 14 violation
Explainability (XAI) AI must justify its recommendations LIME, SHAP techniques; Digital India Act
HITL Human must be final decision-maker High-stakes admin decisions
Zweckrationalität Means-end rationality (Weber) — AI's mode Vs. value rationality of conscience
Wertrationalität Value rationality — conscience's mode Weber's distinction
Kant on AI AI cannot be a Kantian moral agent No will, no duty, no dignity
Phronesis (Aristotle) Practical wisdom — hallmark of good admin Cannot be programmed
Compassion deficit AI cannot feel empathy Widow pension, drought victim examples
DBT and exclusion errors Aadhaar-DBT has genuine beneficiary exclusions Human override needed
Rajasthan context Jan Aadhar, e-Dharti, NDVI drought AI Collector retains conscience duty
Responsible AI for All NITI Aayog, 2021 India's ethical AI framework
India AI Mission Rs 10,372 crore, 2024 Compute, data, safety focus